ELF Beauty Encyclopedia Sparkle Eye Edition

This is an okay palette.  Luckily, it's only $5, so if you don't like it, you haven't wasted much money.  These eye shadows are a mixed bag.  The first four are chalky and not pigmented at all.  The second four are slightly more pigmented, and not nearly as chalky as the first four, but they wear off quickly.  The last four are very similar to the second four, except the black, which is essentially permanent, and extremely dark.  When I wiped my arm, all of the eye shadows disappeared except the sparkly black.